Type of Document Master's Thesis Author Ridley III, Knox Author's Email Address kridley1@student.gsu.edu URN etd-08012007-014011 Title Property without Government Degree Master of Arts Department Philosophy Advisory Committee
Advisor Name Title Dr. Andrew I. Cohen Committee Chair Christie Hartley Committee Member Melissa Merritt Committee Member Keywords
- Property
- Murphy
- Thomas Nagel
- Liam Murphy
- Human Nature
- Philosophy of Property
Date of Defense 2007-07-13 Availability unrestricted Abstract This thesis presents a two part criticism to Liam Murphy and Thomas Nagel’s book, The Myth of Ownership, in which they attempt to argue that it is logically impossible that one can have any entitlement to their pretax income. The first criticism addresses their claim that based on a politically charged understanding of human nature you cannot have property without government. Through the fields of psychology, biology and anthropology, an overlap is found that presents human nature in such a way that presents a serious hurdle to the Murphy and Nagel position. The second criticism addresses their failure to define the scope of government in their book. In light of cultures that have a strong conception of property, Murphy and Nagel are charged with equivocating on the definition of government in order to make their argument hold. The conclusion reached is that based on current research pertaining to human nature and a brief anthropological study, the existence of government is not needed in order to have property within a community.
Files
Filename Size Approximate Download Time (Hours:Minutes:Seconds)
28.8 Modem 56K Modem ISDN (64 Kb) ISDN (128 Kb) Higher-speed Access ridley_knox_200708_ma.pdf 257.65 Kb 00:01:11 00:00:36 00:00:32 00:00:16 00:00:01